End Point Determination Using the Caleva Mixer Torque Rheometer

A company wished to move a formulation currently undergoing product development from small scale laboratory (with batches of 50 grams) to the next stage for a larger scale batch trial of 100 kg (scale–up).  The development had been started using a small Caleva Multi Lab bench top mixer (maximum batch capacity 50 gram of wet mass). This development had been successful and now additional samples were required for larger scale trials.

The granulator on the Caleva Multi Lab is a very small high shear mixer with a 50 g batch capacity but the only mixer/granulator available for use in the development laboratory was 6 kg planetary mixer with different bowl geometry, size and a different mixing action. No data was available for the larger planetary mixer.Mixer Torque Rheometer or the hand squeeze test?
The problem was how the equivalent mixing time could be determined quickly and efficiently in the larger sample using a completely different mixing bowl geometry (round, not square), batch size (x 120 times larger) and mixing method (low shear) to be rheologically equivalent to the granulation used in the smaller scale trials.

The key parameter used for the results of a comparison between two granulating methods was a quantitative assessment of the consistency of the wet granulation as measured with the Caleva Mixer Torque Rheometer (MTR). The Caleva MTR has shown to be a reliable method to quantify the consistency of a granulation or wet mass. This is a replacement of the subjective, but common, “hand squeeze test”.

An assessment was made as part of the small scale formulation development (using a different trial process in the MTR) of the optimum binder content for the formulation under test. The binder content established remained constant during all the test to compare mixing methods.

The mixing bowl of the Caleva Multi Lab has the same geometry and mixing action as the mixing bowl in the MTR and the results from the two bowls are interchangeable and identical. The difference being that the mixing bowl in the MTR is instrumented and can be used to generate useful rheological data.

Figure 1: A graph showing the consistency of an experimental formulation compared to mixing time with a constant mixing and automatic reading. The results show the mean from five separate trials.

Consistency of formulation compared to mixing time

The experimental formulation was mixed in the small high shear bowl of the MTR and the consistency was automatically measured at fixed periods of time. The results are shown in Figure 1 on the previous page.

The results above show that to achieve the maximum torque (the point when the formulation is considered to have reached an optimum formulation end point) a mixing time of about 7.5 to 8.0 minutes was required in the Mixer Torque Rheometer bowl.

In order to determine when the “end point” would be reached in the larger and very different mixer it would be necessary to mix the material in the larger mixer and take small samples to make an assessment

A 6 kilo batch was added to the larger granulator and mixed. As the mixing progressed 40 gram samples were removed after 12, 14, 16, 18, and 20 minutes of mixing. The samples were tested in the MTR to give an individual reading of the consistency of the sample. This is a simple test in the MTR that takes less then a minute for each sample.

RESULTSTime in minutes to reach end point in high shear and planetary mixer


Figure 2: The results from the second trial with the planetary mixer shown on the same graph as the results from the smaller high shear bowl for comparison.

From the comparison of the results it can be seen that:

  • Both mixing systems produce products that show equivalent rheological consistency.
  • The high shear mixer achieves this end point after about 7 to 8 minutes of mixing whereas in the larger and less efficient mixer the mixing time required is about 20 minutes.
  • The Caleva Mixer Torque Rheometer shows in these simple and quick trials that this instrument can be used for “end point” determination to achieve rheologically consistent results with mixtures processed in different granulating systems.

Learn More

By Dr Steve Robinson
17 Apr 2018 in Mixer Torque Rheometer

Leave A Comment




Talk To Caleva

Does the Caleva Mixer/Granulator/Blender allow me to mix and test small batches of product?

We are frequently asked for information about the ability of the small mixer/granulator/blender, a must have tool for any laboratory needing to complete these processes quickly with small sample sizes. Recent trials provide new information about the capability of the Caleva mixer/granulator/blender ... Read More

Book a live online demonstration with Caleva

Are you interested in one of our products and would like to see it in action? We provide free R&D system demonstrations live online via video conference wherever you are in the world. Scott Humphries or Steve Mate (or both) will explain and demonstrate advanced equipment features and allow you t... Read More

Caleva Study on the Importance of Granulation

Our customer, a major pharmaceutical, biotech & nutraceutical manufacturer with an extensive portfolio of products. For reasons of confidentiality we do not name them. One of our Production Extruder & Spheronizer Systems for manufacturing on a large-scale was used in trials by the manufactur... Read More

Shaped Catalyst Body Preparation with MTR and Caleva Screw Extruder

 Shaped Catalyst Body Preparation. Zeolite HZSM-5 (ACS Materials, M38) was mixed as a dry powder with alumina (Sasol, Catapal D (Boehmite)) and the required amount of Milli-Q water to ensure an optimum solid-to-liquid ratio for extrusion (measured using a Mixer Torque Rheometer, Caleva). The paste, ... Read More

Caleva explain the basic Mixer Torque Rheometer concepts - Video

The MTR can process from 10g to 25 g of your material, depending on the formulation, meaning barely any material is wasted in experiments.  The machine will very quickly tell you the ideal amount of liquid to add.  The user may have a start point in mind but this may result in a formulation that is ... Read More

Opportunities for Mixer Torque Rheometry

Wet granulations are a useful precursor to many solid dosage formulations and as such are widely used in the pharmaceutical industry. Because of the diverse nature of pharmaceutical materials, granulation is often employed as an intermediate process to enhance flow and compaction properties and impr... Read More

How much product should be used in the MTR and how accurate is it?

How much product do you use?  The answer is that this is always product specific. This is demonstrated in this article.  In these experiments the MTR is used in the multiple addition mode whereby increasing binder content is automatically added to different masses of product.  The Caleva Mixer Torqu... Read More

Can temperature during granulation influence formulation consistency?

The temperature of the mix during granulation processes is generally considered to be of minor significance in both formulation development and in large batch granulation despite the fact that in some locations ambient temperature can change significantly during the course of a working day. The MTR ... Read More

A Tool For Preformulation Assessment Of Excipients

  Excipients from different batches or vendors may be variable in quality and it is often necessary to perform pre-formulation assessment for each batch of excipient received. In some cases, excipients from different vendors require comparative assessment of their equivalent functionality. In this t... Read More

A better way to granulate with your viscous and sticky materials

Our new High Viscosity Mixing Blades, designed for making those sticky, viscous, difficult, granulations much simpler.  Our design team have been working tirelessly to come up with a solution to a constantly asked question.  Read More

How long should I granulate my materials?

Variable Mix Time Test It is well-known that a minimum amount of mixing is required to ensure consistent and repeatable product characteristics. What is often less considered is the possibility of over-mixing the product so that the characteristics of the resulting formulation undergo a change. Read More

How do I ensure consistency during scale up?

Consistency Measurement A direct consistency measurement of a small sample (generally around 40 g) taken from a process as it is ongoing.  This allows for accurate comparisons to be made quickly, accurately, and repeatable way. Read More

Formulation development - determine optimum powder to binder ratio

Multiple Addition Test Binder liquid is added to a dry powder mix and the consistency is measured as the mixing and addition of binder progresses. The consistency of the mix is measured at regular periods so that the relationship between the amount of liquid binder added to the mix and the consisten... Read More

What characteristics should my extrudate have?

Extrusion and spheronization is not always completely straightforward.  A formulation required for spheronization needs to go through the following processes and achieve the following properties. Read More

Can I spheronize a granulation and skip the extrusion process?

In some circumstances it is possible to omit the extrusion stage, but the results may not be what you need. It is dependent on what you need to achieve with your result and what you want to do in the next phase of the project. Whether or not you decide to include the extrusion stage will depend on w... Read More

Mixing trials with a Caleva Mixer Granulator and difficult materials

Two different products were tested to help a customer who was finding some difficulty in obtaining homogeneous mixes of small volumes. These materials were considered difficult to mix to a homogeneous state in the batch sizes required. PRODUCT 1, TRIAL 1 A mix of sugar and salt in the ratio of 2:1 A... Read More

How to produce consistent formulations from different mixers

Customer Quote: Mr. K.S (Aurobindo) "It is exciting to see the correlation between the two graphs and granulation end point".  With a major pharmaceutical manufacturer, together we characterised all their various mixers to produce a consistent formulation. To identify three important characteristics... Read More

Mixing and granulating small batches

The Caleva Multi-Lab (CML) is capable of performing 3 different processes: Mixing, Extrusion and Spheronization. This article is about the mixing and granulation phase of the process. The multi-lab works with a large range of materials from pharmaceutical materials and catalysts, to agricultural pro... Read More

Do excipients purchased from different vendors behave in the same way?

The Mixer Torque Rheometer can be used to assess the behaviour of excipients purchased from different suppliers. Background Excipients from different batches or vendors may be variable in quality and it is often necessary to perform pre-formulation assessment for each batch of excipient received.  I... Read More

The Caleva Family of Laboratory Equipment

Whilst you may have heard of Caleva and any one of its flagship pieces of equipment, we'd like to introduce you to the family of Caleva laboratory equipment that you may find helpful for your application in your industry sector.  Choose one process or choose all of them.  Select further functions as... Read More

Inconsistent spheronization results with difficult active ingredient?

The following case study demonstrates how the Caleva Mixer Torque Rheometer.  The MTR-3 was an invaluable aid in a specific case. A manufacturer of generic Venlafaxine pellets was experiencing inconsistent results from their manufacturing line. The resultant product was variable in both usable yield... Read More

Mixer Torque Rheometer used with Food Powders

Research Article University of Padova where their Caleva Rheometer was used   Abstract Vegetable soups are complex mixtures containing vegetables in different percentages, thickeners, salt, fat, and emulsifying/wetting agents. When prepared as dehydrated powders in convenience foods, they need to be... Read More

The Importance of End Point Detection Consistency

This world is not only for us. Can you imagine world had no animals, what would it be like? Would the trees be green? Without birds or squirrels, less trees would grow. There would be no pets, no flowers and no bees. If even one part of our ecosystem is removed, we will all die. Without animals, we ... Read More

Caleva Multi Lab & Bone Regeneration study Medical University Gdańsk

Drug-loaded mesoporous silica/calcium phosphate composites for bone regeneration Adrian Szewczyk at Department of Physical Chemistry, Faculty of Pharmacy, Medical University of Gdańsk has kindly allowed us to introduce this paper that introduces a study of Drug-loaded mesoporous silica/calcium phosp... Read More

Agglomeration properties of gluten-free flours under water addition and shearing conditions

The different states of agglomeration were identified by the evolution of rheological properties under water addition and shearing conditions using a Caleva® mixer torque rheometer.  Read More

How reproducible can measurements be of something that is not homogeneous?

The MTR-3 uniquely offers a means of characterising the rheological properties of a wet granulation by providing a quantitative value of the consistency of the material tested. The more traditional hand squeeze test, previously widely used, to measure or compare granulations, is falling into disrepu... Read More

Yield problems in production and quality control

One of the strengths of the Caleva Mixer Torque Rheometer (MTR-3) is that it can be used to verify the properties of wet powder mass samples taken during production in large scale mixer/granulator systems. It can be used simply as a quality control tool on a regular basis or specifically as an aid t... Read More

How the Mixer Torque Rheometer resolved a tablet friability issue

Caleva worked closely with a well known producer of food supplements made from natural materials, plant extracts and other natural food sources.  Their tablet formulations work well and this nutraceutical company has a good reputation for their products.  Generally they do not encounter problems wit... Read More

Determination of moisture requirement to prepare spheroids by extrusion-spheronization

Spheroids are popularly used in the design of multi-particulate drug delivery systems. Extrusion and spheronization is commonly employed to manufacture spheroids in the pharmaceutical industry. It is a multiple-step manufacturing process which could be summarized into the flow chart as shown in Figu... Read More

Save Time and Cost in Formulation Development

In the mid 1990’s, the field of pyrotechnics was limited mainly to applications in aircraft ordnance, fireworks and rock blasting. This has been developed to a highly advanced science and is an extensively used technology which finds application in spacecraft, aircraft and underwater vehicle systems... Read More

End Point Determination Using the Caleva Mixer Torque Rheometer

A company wished to move a formulation currently undergoing product development from small scale laboratory (with batches of 50 grams) to the next stage for a larger scale batch trial of 100 kg (scale–up).  The development had been started using a small Caleva Multi Lab bench top mixer (maximum batc... Read More

Caleva Mixer Torque Rheometer - The importance of mixing time for your formulation development and production

It is well established and understood that one of the most important factors in the development of a formulation for both tableting and making pellets by extrusion and spheronization is the amount of liquid binder added to the formulation. What is less widely acknowledged is the importance of mixing... Read More